Traditional Crust or Crumb Topping
Traditional, Bourbon or Chocolate available
The Salted Honey Pie is sure to impress all of your guest with its creamy texture enhanced by locally sourced honey and Barrier Island Sea Salt. This pie is one of our most requested pies, most compare it to a crème brûlée flavor.
A creamy cheesecake filling with cranberries swirled throughout topped with a buttery crumb topping.
One of our newest creations that has quickly become a fan favorite. Chocolate filling set in a flaky crust topped with homemade Bourbon caramel sauce and pecans.
A creamy orange custard filled with fresh cranberries and topped with a buttery crumb crust. Our Cream Crumble pies are a fan favorite.
Smith Island cakes are the perfect ratio of cake to frosting and definitely a shore tradition. Nine layers of moist cake with frosting is sure to delight everyone this holiday. Flavors available: Chocolate, Double Chocolate, Coconut or Pumpkin.
7 cupcakes featuring our vanilla or chocolate cake finished off as beautiful Autumn flowers and greenery created with our buttercream frosting. Our Cupcake Bouquets are visually stunning and make a wonderful centerpiece for your Holiday celebration.
3 layers of sweet moist cake filled with apples, spices and nuts with a maple cream cheese frosting finished off with a salted caramel drizzle and apple crisps. Feeds 10-12
Our signature bread pudding made from our cinnamon rolls topped with salted caramel sauce. Feeds 6
A 9 inch butter rum bundt cake topped with a praline frosting and the core filled with praline pecans roasted in house.
A dozen of our Sugar cookies decorated as pumpkins for the holiday In our buttercream frosting.
Fluffy Sweet Potato Biscuits available by the half dozen and dozen. Top these southern gems off with Honey Butter or stuff them with ham.
A dozen or half dozen of Pimento Cheese Biscuits
Fluffy Sweet Potato yeast rolls by the half dozen or dozen.
Half dozen of mini bacon cheddar scones
A 9 inch buttery crust filled with your choice of 4 cheese, Ham Swiss, Broccoli Cheddar, Bacon Gouda or Sausage Cheddar
A pastry box filled with a bakers choice of muffins, scones, turnovers and danishes. 18 pieces included.
Be sure to have those cinnamon rolls waiting for your crowd! Order by the half dozen.
All Holiday Orders must be sent to coastalbakingcoorders@gmail.com with subject line Thanksgiving 2026. Order by Thursday, November 19th. Pickups will be scheduled for the 23rd and 24th. Please state the date, time you will be picking up and what name the order will be under. Pickup dates are November 23 -26, 8am-1pm. We will be closed Thanksgiving Day.