555 Mason Ave., Cape Charles, VA 23310

(757) 331-2482

(757) 331-2482

  • Home
  • Bakery Menu
  • Cafe Menu
  • Easter Menu
  • Wedding Info
  • More
    • Home
    • Bakery Menu
    • Cafe Menu
    • Easter Menu
    • Wedding Info
  • Home
  • Bakery Menu
  • Cafe Menu
  • Easter Menu
  • Wedding Info
Coastal Baking Co.

Indulge in Our Sweet Easter Creations

    Easter Menu / Price List

    Signature Pies

    Amazing Salted Honey Pie

    26

    The Salted Honey Pie is sure to impress all of your guest with its creamy texture enhanced by locally sourced honey and Barrier Island Sea Salt. This pie is one of our most requested pies, most compare it to a crème brûlée flavor. 

    Carrot Cake Cheesecake Tart

    28

    A creamy cheesecake filling with chunks of carrot cake swirled throughout set in a Biscoff crust topped with a crumb topping.

    Pistachio Custard Pie

    28

    Rich creamy pistachio filling baked in a lemon shortbread crust garnished with crushed pistachios.

    Blueberry or Raspberry Cream Crumble Pie

    26

    A creamy custard filled with fresh blueberries or Raspberries and topped with a buttery crumb crust. Our Cream Crumble pies are a fan favorite.


    Cakes and Desserts

    Smith Island Cake

    93

    Smith Island cakes are the perfect ratio of cake to frosting and definitely a shore tradition. Nine layers of moist cake with frosting is sure to delight everyone this holiday. Flavors available:  Chocolate, Coconut & Carrot..

    Signature Carrot Cake

    45

    3 layers of our decadent carrot cake with cream cheese frosting garnished with nuts. 

    Cupcake Bouquet

    39

    7 cupcakes featuring our vanilla or chocolate cake finished off as beautiful spring flowers and greenery created with our buttercream frosting. Our Cupcake Bouquets are visually stunning and make a wonderful centerpiece for your Easter celebration. You can choose Vanilla or Chocolate cupcake flavors.

    Bread Pudding

    24

    Our signature bread pudding made from our cinnamon rolls topped with salted caramel sauce.  Feeds 6

    Limoncello Cake

    42

    Light, fluffy bundt cake that has sweet and tart lemon flavor in every bite finished with a limoncello icing decorated with piped buttercream blooms.

    Hummingbird Cake

    48

    3 layers of deliciously spiced moist cake with flavors of banana, walnuts and pineapple. Topped off with our cream cheese frosting.


    Cookies and Candy

    DIY Cookie Kit

    24

    A dozen of Easter themed cookies ready for you to decorate with sprinkles, candies and Buttercream Frosting. Easter activity sheets included with package. DIY Kits are always a delightful family activity.

    Sugar Cookies

    38

    A dozen of our Sugar Cookies decorated for the holiday in our buttercream frosting.

    Easter Cookies

    24

    Share the meaning of Easter with this box of 14 decorated sugar cookies. Each cookie represents a scripture from the Bible. Printable about the cookies and scripture included.  

    Chocolate Covered Eggs

    8.25

    Chocolate covered eggs filled with your choice of peanut butter, coconut cream or Biscoff cream decorated for Easter with spring flowers. Personalized eggs are .50 extra

    PYO Easter Egg Cookies

    14

    A dozen mini frosted egg shape cookies ready to decorate with edible food paint.


    Breads and Pastries

    Sweet Potato Biscuits

    12+

    Fluffy Sweet Potato Biscuits available by the half dozen and dozen. Top these southern gems off with Honey Butter or stuff them with ham.  Half dozen $12, Dozen $18

    Pimento Cheese Biscuits

    12+

    A dozen or half dozen of Pimento Cheese Biscuits. Half dozen $12, Dozen $18

    Sweet Potato Rolls

    12+

    Fluffy Sweet Potato yeast rolls by the half dozen or dozen. 

    Croissants

    16

    Flaky buttery croissants sold by the half dozen.

    Hot Cross Buns

    15+

    Sweet Buns filled with spices and raisins decorated with a white frosted cross. Half dozen $15, Dozen $25


    Breakfast

    Bacon Cheddar Scones

    12

    Half dozen of mini bacon cheddar scones accented with chives.

    Quiche

    26

    A choice of 4 cheese, Ham Swiss, Broccoli Brunch or Sausage Cheddar

    Breakfast Pastry Box

    52

    A pastry box filled with a bakers choice of muffins, scones, turnovers and danishes. 18 pieces included.

    Cinnamon Rolls

    22

    Half Dozen of our Cinnamon Rolls. 

    Easter Donuts

    18

    Half Dozen donuts decorated for Easter.

    All Holiday Orders must be sent to coastalbakingcoorders@gmail.com by Wednesday, April 1st. Please state the day you will be picking up and what name the order will be under.


    Copyright © 2026  Coastal Baking Co. - All Rights Reserved.

    Powered by

    • Easter Menu
    • Wedding Info